Should my pregnancy supplement be tailored to me?

Pregnancy supplements now come with iron or without, with iodine or without, and with folic acid or methylfolate. Each version is sold as the more personal choice.

It is true that no two pregnant women have the same diet, absorption, nutrient levels or medical history, but how far a supplement can be tailored depends on what the evidence supports, and that differs from one nutrient to the next. Below I cover iron, iodine and the folic acid versus methylfolate question. For the basics of which nutrients matter and why, see my article "Is my diet good enough for my baby?".

Should I take iron in pregnancy?

It depends on your blood results and your risk of iron deficiency. Your need for iron rises in pregnancy because your red blood cell volume expands and your baby and placenta take iron too. Deficiency can cause anaemia and is associated with poorer outcomes for mothers and babies.

There are two approaches. The World Health Organization recommends daily iron and folic acid for all pregnant women, particularly where anaemia is common. UK practice is different: we identify women who are iron deficient or anaemic and treat them, and avoid high doses for women who do not need them.

In practice, your routine antenatal blood count shows whether you are anaemic. I also take into account your diet, any previous iron deficiency, bleeding, a multiple pregnancy and relevant medical conditions. Where I suspect low iron stores, I check ferritin, which needs careful reading because inflammation can raise it. Confirmed iron deficiency may need a therapeutic dose, with follow-up to check that you tolerate it and that it is working.

A normal haemoglobin does not always mean your iron stores are adequate, and a low one does not always mean iron deficiency, because other conditions cause anaemia.

A 2024 Cochrane review of 57 trials involving 48,971 women found that daily iron may reduce anaemia and iron deficiency and probably reduces iron-deficiency anaemia at term. It also found probable benefit for low birthweight, although the certainty varied by outcome. Assessing each woman individually can spare you unnecessary high-dose iron and its digestive side effects. It does not show that the low dose in a routine pregnancy supplement is unnecessary.

Do I need an iodine supplement?

The RCOG recommends a total iodine intake of about 200–250 micrograms a day in pregnancy and while breastfeeding, from food, a supplement or both. Its 2025 guideline on thyroid disorders in pregnancy suggests eating more iodine-rich foods or considering a daily 150-microgram supplement.

Your body uses iodine to make thyroid hormones, which your baby needs for brain development. In early pregnancy, before your baby's thyroid is fully working, your baby depends on yours.

It would be neat to test everyone and treat only those who are short, but iodine status is hard to measure in one person:

  • Urine iodine: a spot sample tells us about a population, but varies too much from day to day to diagnose deficiency in you.
  • Thyroid tests: TSH and free T4 show whether your thyroid is working normally. They do not measure iodine.
  • Excess: too much iodine can itself disturb your thyroid and your baby's.
  • Diet: this is the most useful guide. Little dairy, egg or fish, or a mainly plant-based diet, makes a low intake more likely.

For this reason the RCOG advises against routine assessment of individual iodine status with urine iodine or thyroid tests. I look at what you eat, and at any supplement you already take, to judge your total intake.

Severe iodine deficiency clearly harms a baby's brain development, and preventing it is an established public health priority. In mild to moderate deficiency, trials of supplements have not consistently shown better child cognitive outcomes or other major pregnancy benefits, and a Cochrane review found too little evidence to reach firm conclusions on routine supplementation. That uncertainty does not show iodine is unnecessary. It means the benefit of supplementing a mildly deficient population is less certain than the benefit of preventing severe deficiency.

Is methylfolate better than folic acid?

No. Folic acid remains the evidence-based standard, and methylfolate has not been shown to protect against neural tube defects as well.

Folic acid is the synthetic form of vitamin B9 used in supplements and food fortification, and your body converts it into active folate. Taken before conception and in early pregnancy, it has strong evidence for reducing neural tube defects. Methylfolate (5-MTHF) is already the active form, so it skips the step that depends on the MTHFR enzyme. It can raise your folate levels, but there is no equivalent evidence that it prevents neural tube defects.

The MTHFR argument is the main reason manufacturers promote methylfolate. Some variants of the MTHFR gene, particularly C677T, reduce the enzyme's activity and can affect folate and homocysteine levels. Even so:

  • Having a variant does not mean you cannot use folic acid. The CDC states that people with common MTHFR variants can process it.
  • Folic acid raises folate levels even in people with the C677T variant.
  • There is no good evidence that routine MTHFR genetic testing should decide which form of folate you take.

Methylfolate's different biochemistry is real, but it has not been shown to improve outcomes. The UK Teratology Information Service reports that the rates of neural tube defects and other birth defects in babies of women taking methylfolate in pregnancy have not been established, and it does not recommend routinely replacing folic acid with methylfolate.

Claim What the evidence supports
Methylfolate is the active form of folate Yes
Methylfolate bypasses the MTHFR step Yes
Women with MTHFR variants cannot use folic acid No
Methylfolate prevents neural tube defects better than folic acid Not established
Methylfolate is safer in pregnancy Not established
Folic acid is the evidence-based standard Yes

What should a pregnancy supplement contain?

At a minimum, folic acid and vitamin D, with iron and iodine added according to your diet, blood results and medical history.

  • Folic acid: NICE recommends 400 micrograms daily for anyone planning pregnancy and for the first 12 weeks.  A prescribed 5 mg dose is for specified higher-risk groups, including women who have had a pregnancy affected by a neural tube defect and those with certain medical conditions or medicines.
  • Vitamin D: 10 micrograms daily, as the NHS advises for pregnancy.
  • Iron: according to your blood results and risk. A low-dose nutritional formulation and treatment of established deficiency are different decisions.
  • Iodine: according to your diet and the RCOG figure above, without exceeding it.

The UK also plans mandatory folic acid fortification of non-wholemeal wheat flour, scheduled for December 2026. It is meant to add to the advice to take folic acid before conception and in early pregnancy, not replace it.

When should I ask for advice about my supplement?

Ask before you choose one if you have a condition that affects how you absorb or use nutrients. Thyroid disease, malabsorption, previous bariatric surgery and significant nutritional deficiencies may need specialist assessment rather than a standard supplement from a chemist. The same applies if you are planning a pregnancy and think you may need the higher dose of folic acid.

If you are unsure, my advice is to make sure you take an effective dose of folic acid before conception and through early pregnancy, which matters more than any other choice here. I am happy to go through your diet, blood results and medical history and advise on the rest.

Colette, my secretary, can arrange your appointment with me. Please don't hesitate to get in touch or book online.